How a Wall Street Banker brought new life to one of Vermont's Oldest General Stores

Prosper

Thirty years in New York City banking taught Cindy Loudenslager how to close deals. But it took a 200-year-old general store in Vermont to teach her how to open doors—literally, every morning at 7 a.m.

While Wall Street can feed a certain kind of ambition, at least for a season, it doesn't always feed the soul. For Cindy, decades in banking delivered plenty of adrenaline—until Vermont's Green Mountains offered something rarer: quiet that actually sticks. She shared that she was a little burned out on the high-stakes New York life and was truly ready to sink into the pace of southern Vermont.

Dorset was a place that kept calling her back—weekend after weekend—until the pull felt less like a getaway and more like where she belonged.

In 2007, an opportunity arrived that wasn't just real estate or retail. It was mission, stewardship, and a brand new story. As we write about these small town general stores, we hear this often - a cherished general store is looking for a new future and the timing is just right as the new owners show up. Serendipitous? Delightful? or downright magical! (Read about our Mainstreet Maven Jillian Minerva, who with her husband, runs the Barnstad General Store in northern Vermont)

Quick Facts:

Founded: 1816 (one of the oldest stores in the nation)
Owners since 2007: Cindy Loudenslager & Gretchen Schmidt
Location: 31 Church Street, on Dorset's village green
What makes it special: Full-service deli, scratch bakery, wine room, Vermont products, marble sidewalks outside
Must-try: Fresh baked goods baked every day.

Why Dorset’s General Store is the heart of town

Many Mainstreet Maven interviews happen on a busy block—crosswalks, storefronts, coffee cups in motion. Dorset is different. It's a hamlet with the posture of a postcard. The village center sits within the Dorset Village Historic District, complete with unusual touches like marble sidewalks from local quarries and with clapboard siding houses lining the main drive.. Pictures of Dorset through the decades have barely changed.

So yes—quieter, much quieter than a Manhattan block. Bucolic, even.

But the impact of running a general store in a place like this becomes even more profound. Because when a town is small, the places that bring people together aren't optional. They're essential.

Small moves here create fairly profound ripple effects.

In my conversation with Cindy, it wasn't the title "owner" that stood out. It was the way she saw opportunity in simple gestures—like setting out picnic tables and benches on the town green. Whether you're a visitor indulging in fresh baked goods or a local enjoying an evening bottle of wine, these tables welcome you.

A small move. Epic impact. For her store and for the community and it was just the beginning.

That's the thing about general stores done right: they don't just sell what people need. They make it easier for people to belong.

208 Years of History: The Dorset Union Store Timeline

The Dorset Union Store's story reaches back to 1816—making it one of the oldest continuously operating stores in America.

There's even local lore that the building itself was moved from nearby East Rupert before becoming what Dorset came to rely on.

The store originally operated like a cooperative, with members owning shares. Over the years, the name and ownership shifted through several hands:

1839: Sold and became Moore Holley & Co.
Various iterations: S.F. Holley & Co., Holley & Gray, Underhill & Gray, Clark Gray
1851: Name restored to Dorset Union Store
1926: Peltier & Tifft took over
1955: Perry Peltier became sole owner; locals called it "Peltier's" (pronounced "pel-chers")
1977-2007: Jay and Terri Hathaway ran the store, raising their family in the apartment upstairs
2007: Cindy and Gretchen purchased it and restored the original nameiberkshires+1

That's when the current chapter began—and with it, the work of protecting the spirit of the place while making it viable for modern life.

From Wall Street to Main Street: Cindy's Journey

Cindy came with a career's worth of grit—about 30 years in the New York City banking world.

Gretchen came with deep local roots and entrepreneurial experience. She'd owned the Dorset Inn, just across the green, and knew the community inside out.

They met in Dorset at a golf event (because Vermont has a way of making even networking feel like fresh air), and the partnership that followed became both personal and professional.

In the early years after purchasing the store, this was a two-state life. Cindy commuted up from New York while Gretchen carried the day-to-day rhythm until Cindy could be in Dorset full-time. (That commute is a little over 4 hours or a plane ride to Albany.)

They knew the store needed reinvestment, some repositioning, new fixtures, before it could capture their vision. They moved the deli to the back and enlarged it. (Oh, the offerings now!! YUM!)

They expanded their staff, adding two chefs (Rick and Connie)and a pastry chef(Lori). They also vastly expanded their food and pastry offerings. Today, in total they have ten full time employees, nine part-time employees plus some college students during high season in the summer.

It's easy to romanticize buying a country store. It's much harder to romanticize the years of commuting, planning, investing, and holding steady while you rebuild a legacy business one decision at a time. Their knowledge of the town and the business has served them well.

What Makes a Modern General Store Work

Cindy and Gretchen understood something that a lot of small towns quietly learn the hard way:

If a general store is going to survive today, it can't just trade in nostalgia. It has to trade in usefulness.

They hired a General Manager (Paul) and his wife (Julia) as head of catering.

Under their leadership, the Dorset Union Store became a true one of a kind, one-stop shop again:

Coffee bar and bakery
Full-service deli with prepared foods
Fresh meat and produce
Vermont-made products (maple syrup, cheese, jam)
Wine room and craft beer selection
Homemade frozen dinners
Catering services

They made updates while preserving the footprint and the feeling—an approach Cindy describes as protecting the store as a historic site while letting it evolve.

The weathered wood floors still creak under your steps. A bell still greets visitors when they walk through the door. You can still find penny candy on the shelves.

But now you can also grab a gourmet sandwich, pick up dinner, or choose from a curated wine selection.

Cindy’s passion for excellent food, a variety of choices, and a wine room that serves an afternoon glass among friends and the most special of occasions, was evident throughout our conversation. While she brings a business acumen, first and foremost is delivering the best food choices to her community.

Celebrating 200 Years (and Counting)

When the store celebrated its 200th birthday in July 2016, the party spilled out onto the green. Tables filled with scratch-made food prepared by head baker and chef. Old-fashioned games. Live music. A giant canopy covering the festivities. It was quite a celebration!

It doesn’t take a milestone anniversary to celebrate though and Cindy is sure that the store is in the center of it.

Community events the store helps organize:

The Annual Fall Festival that lands on Columbus Day Weekend where the beautiful foliage season is celebrated by visitors and locals alike.
Town-wide Halloween costume party on the green (with Cindy in costume)
Giant Easter egg hunt (featuring Cindy as the holiday bunny)
Regular gatherings that turn the green into a shared living room

The Maven Move: Turning "A Store" Into "The Place"

Here's what makes Cindy a Mainstreet Maven, even without a stoplight outside her door:

She's not simply keeping shelves stocked. She's crafting and protecting a daily ritual. It starts with fresh roasted coffee, fresh baked goods, and the essentials. She has brought her energy from her banking career to develop efficient managment, without losing the heart of the store. She definitely has embraced this community, coming up on 20 years next year, as her own.

Because of her attention to detail, there is room for neighbors catch up between the cookie jars and the deli case. Visitors feel welcome immediately, if not overwhelmed with the options before them. The bell over the door keeps doing what it has done for generations—announcing that someone has arrived, as does the screen door in the summer. I have visited this store quite a few times and the hum and activity never ceases to amaze me. You just want to hang out on the front steps and watch the town.

That's what a modern general store really is: part market, part meeting place, part unofficial town hall—minus the agenda, plus pastry.

In a small town, that role isn't "nice." It's structural, and essential.

"We wanted to return the store to its roots," Cindy says. "Preserving the store as a historic site was one of our biggest incentives to buy it in the first place."

You can see and feel the attention put into the store as it has soaked up the reinvestment, but preservation doesn't mean standing still. It means honoring what matters—the bell, the floors, the ritual of gathering—while adapting everything else to serve people better. Anyone active in preservation can tell you that holding a value in the community’s economy is the most significant tell of long term preservation.

Why This Matters Beyond Dorset

The Dorset Union Store sits in the Dorset Village Historic District, where marble sidewalks and unchanged architecture create a sense of continuity that most places have lost.

But what Cindy and Gretchen have built isn't about preserving the past. It's about protecting a future where small towns still have beating hearts. We often talk about our “third-places”, that place other than home or work where you belong. The green and the store are Dorset’s “third-place and is essential to it’s culture.

Because here's the truth about community-centered retail in small towns: when the general store closes, something more than convenience disappears. The daily touchpoints vanish. The reason to walk to the green fades. The unofficial gathering place goes quiet. In other towns it can be a cafe, a tavern, or a central green - but in almost every town it used to be the general store.

Cindy left a high-powered banking career not to escape, but to build. To show up early. To set out tables. To organize egg hunts. To make sure that when someone walks through that door, the bell still rings and someone notices.

That's the work. And in a world that moves faster every year, it's becoming rarer—and more essential—all the time. We are delighted to have come to know this amazing Mainstreet Maven!

Planning a visit to Vermont's small towns? The Dorset Union Store is open daily at 31 Church Street in Dorset. Stop in for coffee, stay for the experience—and if you see Cindy, ask her about the commute from Wall Street to Main Street. It's a story worth hearing.

Instagram - Too far to pop in? Check out their Instagram for ongoing inspiration!

Website - Learn more and keep up with their new offerings.

Have you ever walked away from a successful career to follow a quieter calling? Share your story here, or tag us when you visit Dorset.